Paul Grim: RIM’s Burning Platform

Nokia CEO Stephen Elop made the symbolic leap off of the burning platform, and joined forces with Microsoft. There were rumors that both Android and Windows Phone 7 were in the running to supplant Symbian and save the once-dominant mobile phone maker, and of course Elop’s prior tenure at Microsoft might have helped the process along. But this is truly a bold move, and a smart one (for both Microsoft and Nokia).

The wireless ecosystem has witnessed dramatic, tectonic shifts in the past two years, all of which are good for consumers and application developers. Many wise men in the industry spoke of continued fragmentation of platforms, and to this I again say “pshaw!” Before this decision, the industry was morphing at warp speed into an Apple/Android duopoly.

To wit:
– Android-powered smartphones decimated RIM’s market share in Verizon smartphone sales (dropping from 93% to 19% in only 12 months!!), and soon surpassed even Apple’s sales overall
-Apple now begins the counter-punch in the US, with the Verizon launch
Android releases its new OS – Honeycomb – and makes a tablet play to combat the iPad phenomenon
-Apple inevitably prepares to launch a low-cost iPhone to combat the low-cost Android handsets

Meanwhile, what happened to the other platform providers?
-Microsoft launches Kin, pulls after one month. They then launch Phone 7 with half a billion dollars in marketing, and Christmas shipments disappointed.
-Nokia dithered, played with MeeGo, and even took a cheap shot at the other handset makers
-Palm released a great OS, but ‘twas a party to which no one came. The company sold to HP, who now isn’t quite sure why they bought it.
-The feature-phone application developers using Brew and other tools are rapidly jumping to smartphones, because pretty soon that’s all there will be left.

So now, faced with the prospect of metaphorical immolation, Nokia has leaped into the chilly waters of Phone7, hoping to spot a life raft. Given the massive installed base of Symbian phones in Europe and Asia, this could realistically turn the smartphone duopoly into a triopoly, and save both Nokia and Microsoft Mobile in the process.

So where does this leave Blackberry? Well, they are the last ones left standing on that burning platform.

RIM, the company that arguably started it all in the smartphone world, is now facing an existential strategic dilemma. Once the preeminent enterprise smartphone of choice, it is now being hounded on all sides by the iPhone and Android phenomenon. Despite several smart acquisitions such as QNX, its phones still do not measure up to its competitors in any feature other than (of course) email. The average corporate user would always be the laggard in giving up the secure, reliable, and rock-solid email phone for some flaky touch-screen battery hog; however, even they are now migrating away.

So what can they do? For a long time, I thought that the best match would be to partner with Microsoft, but that ship may now have sailed. Microsoft still has its eye on the enterprise market, and RIM’s foothold there is still strong, but then again Apple wants to break in as well. And yet Apple is finally finding (oddly enough, with the iPad) its own way into the enterprise opportunity.

One interesting sign of where they might be headed is today’s announcement that RIM’s Playbook tablet will support Android apps. Is this a first tentative step toward partnering with Google, or does becoming yet another handset OEM fundamentally negate what RIM is all about? Maybe it’s better than being up on that platform.

Paul Grim is a founder and general partner with SunBridge Partners. He writes a blog called Grim Times and tweets @jprgrim on Twitter.

4 Comments

  • [...] peHUB » Paul Grim: RIM’s Burning Platform pehub.com/95732/paul-grim-rims-burning-platform/ – view page – cached Private Equity Hub (peHub) is an interactive forum for the private equity community, which includes venture capitalists, buyouts professionals, attorneys, bankers, entrepreneurs, MBA candidates studying PE, and assorted hangers-on. Its mission is simple: To help you do your job better, by feeding your head with news and views from/about your peers. Show influential only (1) $(‘#filter-infonly’).change(function() { var el = $(this); var url = document.location.href; var checked = el.attr(‘checked’); if (checked) { document.location.href = url + ((/?/.test(url)) ? ‘&’ : ‘?’) + ‘infonly=1′; } else { document.location.href = url.replace(/[?&]?infonly=1/,”); } }); [...]

  • Elop has made a terrible mistake last friday. I’m not saying that going Microsoft is bad but simply that he as told too much truth to justify himself within Nokia as he refered to the burning platform. This is going to create a headache for his sales team trying to keep selling Sabian for the next year. Phone companies and consumers will stop buying this platform which will further reduce sales and margins. This is a real mess and I can assure you that having worked for a Finnish company for over twenty years that they must be regretting having given the keys to the countries biggest employer to a foreigner. This will lead to a revolt company wise and nation wide. So now Nokia who is already suffering at the low end market has now added margin pressure on its high end phones. Furthermore, I question the fact that they have limited their choice to only WP7…why did he not go to both platforms like the other hardware vendors…Nokia is going to become a hardware vendor so why cut away from part of the market by refusing Android? This question is worth asking…Elop is leading this company like an novice that is in a rush to get somewhere….which only he seems to know where…

    RIM on the other hand as been consistent in their finances and with their news OS, their tie with business, their BBM, their security, the future of credit cards through the phones etc… they have a real shot at defining themselves a niche in the smartphone market.

  • The first thing that came to mind is what does Nokia’s move to WP7 mean for RIM? There were six players in the space, but Nokia just threw in the towel. Now there are five. Nokia and RIM have the most to lose and Apple and Google have been transforming the market. WebOS can be contained within HP’s product line and still be relevant even if it isn’t a top 3 smartphone platform in the mobile space and they also have the least to lose. But RIM on the other hand must be freaking out right now. Could we see RIM abandon BBOS for Android or WP7? The Torch is not a compelling device and the Playbook and QNX won’t be enough when there are so many Honeycomb tablets not to mention the Touchpad and iPad2 for consumers to choose from. Their development path is not quick enough and their ecosystem is not strong enough and no Astonishing Tribe will make a difference. Blackberry…your platform is burning.

  • [...] Visit link: Paul Grim: RIM’s Burning Platform – Private Equity Hub (press release) [...]

Leave a Reply

PEHUB Community

Join the 12505 members of peHUB to make connections, share your opinion, and follow your favorite authors.

Join the Community

Look Who’s Tweeting

PE HUB News Briefs

RSS Feed Widget

VCJ Headlines (subscribers only)

RSS Feed Widget

Buyouts Headlines (subscribers only)

RSS Feed Widget

Reuters VC and PE feed

RSS Feed Widget