Following passage of pension legislation last summer, some fund-of-funds managers are finding their money isn’t quite as welcome as it used to be.
David Watson, a partner at law firm Goodwin Procter LLP, said that a ticklish regulatory issue related to the legislation has popped up in three funds that he has negotiated on behalf of buyout shops in recent months. In one case, a fund-of-funds manager failed to secure a spot in a partnership after becoming a less desirable limited partner due to the legislation; in a second case, a funds-of-funds manager overcame the issue to secure a spot in a partnership; and in a third case, a fund-of-funds manager is still in negotiations over the issue.
At first blush, the Pension Protection Act of 2006, signed into law last August, seemed to provide only good news for the buyout market, including funds of funds.
Prior to enactment, buyout firms that wished to avoid the onerous rules of ERISA (Employment Retirement Income Security Act of 1974) had two main choices. The less viable one: Ensure that less than 25 percent of their money came from employee benefit plans, whether or not those plans were governed by ERISA. Many firms chose instead to become venture capital operating companies. The VCOC designation shelters them from having to comply with ERISA.
But here’s the problem for certain funds of funds, according to Watson. Their partnership agreements typically allow for the transfer of limited partnership interests to other investors. According to Goodwin Procter’s interpretation of the new regulations, any question about the future composition of the LP base of a fund of funds means that a buyout firm must treat 100 percent of its commitment as ERISA money. An executive at a funds-of-funds manager pointed out that managers typically can veto the transfer of an interest to another LP. She added that she has not run into the 25 percent-test issue in any of her partnership negotiations.
Watson acknowledged that most funds-of-funds managers can veto LP interest transfers. However, in practice, managers often promise a measure of freedom to investors concerned about illiquidity, he said. In the future, he expects managers to tighten up their transfer policies to avoid the 25 percent-test problem. Alternatively, managers can create separate, parallel partnerships for their ERISA-plan LPs, so that they can still get their non-ERISA clients into funds, he said.
Check out this an other valuable stories on the buyout market at http://www.buyoutsnews.com/. Subscription required for full text of articles.